高等考試
111年
[一般行政] 法學知識與英文(包括中華民國憲法、法學緒論、英文)
第 49 題
📖 題組：
Before there were alarm clocks, how did people wake up at a specific time they wanted to in the morning? Since the Industrial Revolution began in the 1780s, people had been finding ways to make sure they got to work on time. Back then, a knocker-up, also known as a “knocker-upper,” started as a profession to wake people up by knocking on their doors or windows. Even though alarm clocks had been invented in 1787 by American inventor, Levi Hutchins, they were not yet available to the general public in Britain or Ireland. It was common for people in these places to hire knocker-ups to wake them up in the morning. Half a century after the invention of alarm clocks, Frenchman Antoine Redier patented an adjustable alarm clock in 1847. Still, mechanical alarm clocks were not cheap or widely available. Well into the 1920s, most workers in Britain would rather hire knocker-ups. Knocker-ups used a variety of methods to wake up their clients. Some used a baton, or a short, heavy stick, to knock on the client’s door. Some used a long and light stick made of bamboo to reach the client’s window on a higher floor. Still others used a pea-shooter, through which small objects can be blown, to shoot dried peas at their clients’ windows. Their job was to rouse the sleeping clients, and they certainly came up with creative ways to achieve this goal. Knocker-ups would not leave a client’s door or window until they made sure that the client had been awaken. There were large numbers of people carrying out the job, especially in large industrial towns such as Manchester. Knocker-ups were generally elderly men and women, but sometimes police officers would take on the job to earn extra income by performing the task during early morning patrols. But who woke the knocker-uppers? A tongue-twister from the time goes like this: We had a knocker-up, and our knocker-up had a knocker-up And our knocker-up’s knocker-up didn’t knock our knocker up So our knocker-up didn’t knock us up ‘Cos he’s not up. By the 1950s, knocking up had gradually died out in most places due to the wide spread of electricity and affordable alarm clocks. Today, people merely read about anecdotes regarding how knocker-ups woke up their clients creatively or a fun tongue-twister like the one above.
Before there were alarm clocks, how did people wake up at a specific time they wanted to in the morning? Since the Industrial Revolution began in the 1780s, people had been finding ways to make sure they got to work on time. Back then, a knocker-up, also known as a “knocker-upper,” started as a profession to wake people up by knocking on their doors or windows. Even though alarm clocks had been invented in 1787 by American inventor, Levi Hutchins, they were not yet available to the general public in Britain or Ireland. It was common for people in these places to hire knocker-ups to wake them up in the morning. Half a century after the invention of alarm clocks, Frenchman Antoine Redier patented an adjustable alarm clock in 1847. Still, mechanical alarm clocks were not cheap or widely available. Well into the 1920s, most workers in Britain would rather hire knocker-ups. Knocker-ups used a variety of methods to wake up their clients. Some used a baton, or a short, heavy stick, to knock on the client’s door. Some used a long and light stick made of bamboo to reach the client’s window on a higher floor. Still others used a pea-shooter, through which small objects can be blown, to shoot dried peas at their clients’ windows. Their job was to rouse the sleeping clients, and they certainly came up with creative ways to achieve this goal. Knocker-ups would not leave a client’s door or window until they made sure that the client had been awaken. There were large numbers of people carrying out the job, especially in large industrial towns such as Manchester. Knocker-ups were generally elderly men and women, but sometimes police officers would take on the job to earn extra income by performing the task during early morning patrols. But who woke the knocker-uppers? A tongue-twister from the time goes like this: We had a knocker-up, and our knocker-up had a knocker-up And our knocker-up’s knocker-up didn’t knock our knocker up So our knocker-up didn’t knock us up ‘Cos he’s not up. By the 1950s, knocking up had gradually died out in most places due to the wide spread of electricity and affordable alarm clocks. Today, people merely read about anecdotes regarding how knocker-ups woke up their clients creatively or a fun tongue-twister like the one above.
Which of the following best summarizes the tongue-twister mentioned in the passage?
- A Our knocker-up’s knocker-up forgot to wake us up.
- B Our knocker-up’s knocker-up failed to wake him up.
- C We overslept because our knocker-up took the day off.
- D We did not sleep well because our knocker-up was sick.
思路引導 VIP
請試著思考：在一個『甲負責叫醒乙，乙負責叫醒丙』的連環機制中，如果丙最終沒有準時起床，且原因出在最源頭的那個環節，那麼這場失誤最原始的『違約者』與『受害者』分別是誰？
🤖
AI 詳解
AI 專屬家教
恭喜你精準掌握了這題的邏輯核心！這類關於「打更人」（knocker-up）的考題，核心在於理解文中角色層級的遞降關係。在英文閱讀理解中，繞口令（tongue-twister）往往是為了測試考生對所有格修飾語與因果邏輯的辨識能力，你能迅速從中理出頭緒，表現得非常專業。
繞口令中的邏輯連鎖反應
選項 (B) 之所以正確，是因為它點出了整段敘述的「斷裂點」。這段繞口令背後的邏輯鏈條是：我們僱了一位 A（knocker-up）來叫醒我們，而 A 為了確保能準時起床，又僱了 B（knocker-up's knocker-up）來叫醒他。當「A 的叫醒者（B）」**未能成功叫醒 A（failed to wake him up）**時，自然會導致後續 A 無法醒來，進而連帶造成「我們」也沒被叫醒。你能夠在看似繞口的文字中鎖定這層核心因果，顯見你的邏輯歸納能力相當出色。
▼ 還有更多解析內容
英文閱讀：邏輯關係推論
💡 透過所有格與代名詞釐清角色間的因果與從屬關係
🔗 饒口令中的責任連鎖邏輯
- 1 最終對象：客戶 — 依賴敲門人 (A) 準時喚醒以進行工作。
- 2 中間者：敲門人 (A) — 他也需要睡覺，故聘請敲門人 (B) 喚醒他。
- 3 關鍵環節：敲門人 (B) — 即 knocker-up's knocker-up，他是整條鏈條的起點。
- 4 邏輯崩潰 — B 失敗 → A 沒醒 → 客戶沒醒。答案 B 即在描述此斷鏈。
↓
↓
↓
🔄 延伸學習：延伸學習：英文閱讀中常出現此類 recursive (遞迴) 結構來考驗考生的邏輯細心度。
